Friday, September 30, 2005

The Slippery Slope

Thanks to one of my favorite readers for sending along an amazing piece from Slate....

I've gotta say, the longer this pre-Gay Ban period perdures, the more it'll be rued by the Bosses, because every single last story (and the stories could go on forever) about the campy gay clerical culture we've all come to know and love will be blared before the eyes of the world.

Here's a snip
First, banning gay seminarians will only drive the issue underground, precisely the situation before the sexual revolution permitted people—even priests—to be more honest about their sexuality. The most notorious clerical child molesters were all ordained before the sexual revolution and before the changes wrought in the church by the Second Vatican Council (1962-1965). Secrecy and silence encourage immaturity and duplicity, necessary precursors for inappropriate sexual behavior. Second, as my exchange with my friend indicates, many of those priests the right wing considers "their own" are also gay, and only a willful ignorance would fail to see it.

Such a willful ignorance must exist. When I was in the seminary in the mid-1980s, a local bishop came to visit. The bishop dressed for mass in the rectory next door. We seminarians were a bit late in arriving and were met by the bishop's secretary who said, "Come on boys, get into your dresses. Grandma is coming." Grandma was the bishop. The secretary had a feminine nickname, which, I am told, his intimates still use. To complete the screenplay quality of the experience, one of the priests who was in attendance that day left the priesthood shortly thereafter to become a flight steward or, as he called it, "a waitress in the sky." This kind of campiness was common both in the seminary and in my experiences with those already ordained. As for the secretary, he is now a bishop much in favor with conservatives.

The anger about the ban among priests, gay and straight, was more visceral than anything I have ever seen. It is an unwritten rule of gay life that you never, ever "out" a closeted gay person. Everyone has the right to come to terms with their own sexuality in their own way. (I need hardly add that Christians take their name from the master who famously warned against judging others.) Yet, there were threats of outings last week. The hypocrisy of trying to hang the sexual abuse crisis around the neck of gay priests, most of whom are celibate and hardworking, was too much. I know some gay priests who have truly wrestled with their sexuality. As with straight priests, some have fallen from their vows on occasion or on holiday, but most have been largely faithful. Some gay priests are liberal and others are conservative. Some are still conflicted by their sexuality and others are not. What they all share is an almost heroic sense of integrity. To try and blame them for the shiftless careerism that caused bishops to look the other way while children were being abused is beyond the pale.

The last thing the church needs is an anti-gay auto-da-fé.

Reform of the church must always draw upon our tradition, and if Pope Benedict wants to truly address the source of the sexual abuse scandal, he will reinstate the ancient tradition of the church that prevented bishops from being transferred (the technical term is "translated") or promoted from one bishopric to another, more important, diocese. In a stroke, he would remove the careerism that fueled the sweep-it-under-the-rug-at-all-costs syndrome that fostered the crisis. If a man wants to be the bishop of... let him be the bishop of... for the rest of his life. But do not tempt him to fail to face problems in the hopes of becoming the archbishop of New York.

-30-

1 Comments:

Blogger Disgusted in DC said...

"There is a big difference between liberal gay priests and a conservative priest that has had some struggle with same sex attraction."

And what about the "liberal" gay priest who, while having private reservations about the Church's teachings is neverthelss chaste and obedient to the Church? And what about the conservative gay priest who is well known for agreeing with and preaching the Church's teachings on the subject, yet has sex with men on the side? These priests do in fact exist and things are not always what they seem.

"I can see the honest conservation priest with same sex atraction being allowed to persue his vocation and in the process holiness. Someday he will not struggle any more because God will free him from that."

Oh! So if someone struggles and prays hard enough, God will free someone from any sexual interest in the same sex? I don't think Courage makes such claims. Such claptrap claims usually come from idjit evangelical/fundamentalists who preach "name it and claim it" theology, pray the "Prayer of Jabez," and participate in para-church sponsored multi-level marketing schemes hoping to get rich.

1/10/05 11:29  

Post a Comment

<< Home